Back to Wider Views →

Austerity: The Big Lie

How a false economy broke Britain, and why we must stop paying the price.

For 14 years, the British public was subjected to a massive, coordinated gaslighting operation. We were told, repeatedly, that the reason our libraries are closing, our rivers are full of sewage, and our NHS is on its knees is because we simply "ran out of money."

We were told that the country was like a household that had "maxed out its credit card." We were told we had to "tighten our belts." We were told that the pain was necessary, responsible, and inevitable.

I am here to tell you that this was a lie.

The "Household Budget" Myth

To understand the con, you have to understand the analogy they used to sell it. Politicians love to compare the national economy to your household budget. They say: "If a family spends more than it earns, it goes bust. The government is the same."

It sounds like common sense. But it is economic nonsense.

A government is not a household. If you stop spending money at the local shop, the shop doesn't collapse. But the government is the biggest spender in the economy. When the government cuts spending, it isn't just "saving money"; it is removing money from the pockets of nurses, teachers, construction workers, and businesses.

When those people have less money, they spend less. When they spend less, businesses make less profit. When businesses make less profit, the government collects less tax.

By trying to cut the deficit too hard and too fast, austerity actually choked off the growth we needed to pay our debts. It was like seeing your car is low on fuel and deciding to sell the engine to save money. You haven't "balanced the books"; you have wrecked the car.

The Price of "Savings" We are now living in the wreckage of that decision.

Austerity was never about "efficiency." It was an ideological choice to shrink the state. And the cost has been astronomical.

• Our Health: We didn't invest in preventative health or social care, so now our A&Es are overflowing with people who could have been treated sooner and cheaper.
• Our Infrastructure: We slashed budgets for road maintenance and school buildings. Now, we are spending billions patching potholes and propping up our crumbling education system.
• Our Security: We cut police numbers and court budgets, and now we face a backlog of justice that leaves victims in limbo for years.

This is the Green Party perspective: Austerity is a false economy. It is expensive to be poor. It is expensive to let problems fester. It costs infinitely more to fix a flooded town than it does to build flood defences. It costs more to treat chronic illness than to ensure people have warm, insulated homes.

The Green Antidote

The opposite of austerity isn't "reckless spending." It is smart investment.

As a Green, I look at the economy the same way I look at the environment. You don't strip mine the soil today if you want a harvest tomorrow.

We need to reject the "credit card" fear mongering. The UK is one of the richest economies on Earth. We can afford to have a functioning society. We can afford to insulate every home in Britain, lowering bills, creating jobs, and saving the NHS millions in cold-related illnesses. That isn't "spending"; that is investing in an asset that pays us back for decades.

Austerity told us to look at the cost of everything and the value of nothing. It told us that a number on a spread sheet was more important than a child waiting for mental health support or a commuter waiting for a train that never comes.

The 14 years of austerity were a choice. The decay you see around you, in our high streets, our public services, and our environment, was a policy decision.

It is time to make a different choice. It is time to stop apologising for wanting a country that works. It is time to stop tightening our belts and start fixing the roof.